Project Return header banner image

Parents / Caregivers >>
Girls / Youth


AUTHORITATIVE vs. AUTHORITARIAN CAREGIVERS

Authoritative parents and caregivers usually:
  1. Are nurturing
  2. Openly express unconditional love and affection
  3. Set firm, logical limits
  4. Are consistent
  5. Set expectations that are appropriate to the child's developmental stage of life
  6. Practice positive discipline
  7. Are Empathic
  8. Are approachable and encourage open communication with their child
  9. Provide guidance and encouragement
  10. Use consequences logical to the child's misbehavior
  11. Encourage restitution when the their child has wronged another person
  12. Are understanding of the factors and needs underlying their child's behavior
  13. Adjust restrictions according to a child's development to allow for growth and opportunity to demonstrate responsibility
  14. Advocate for or support their child when another adult has wronged their child
  15. Encourage critical thinking skills by allowing their child to question authority when the child feels he or she has been misunderstood
  16. Earn respect from their child by showing their respect to their child
Authoritarian parents and caregivers usually:
  1. Are punitive
  2. Are demanding of blind obedience and compliance
  3. Withdraw love, attention and physical needs if a child misbehaves
  4. Use threats to gain compliance
  5. Mistake age-appropriate behavior for misbehavior
  6. Make rules and demands based on adult convenience
  7. Use corporal punishment
  8. Yell, scream, compare and use put downs
  9. Shame children for poor behavior
  10. Are sarcastic when speaking to their child
  11. Overlook or negate the factors or needs underlying a child's behavior
  12. Are non-democratic
  13. Employ consequences that are illogical to the misbehavior
  14. Use bribes or manipulation to gain compliance
  15. Punish children as a way to "get back at" or to "win" a power struggle
  16. Engage children in power struggles to assert "who's boss"
  17. Put restrictions on a child's freedom, autonomy or individuality in excess of what would be appropriate for the child's age level
  18. Fail to adjust restrictions to allow a child growth
  19. Fail to advocate for or support their child when another adult has wronged their child
  20. Insist on "no back-talk", barring a child from questioning authority when they feel they have been misunderstood
  21. Demand respect from their child without earning it
Permissive parents and caregivers usually:
  1. Fail to adequately set limits and boundaries for their child
  2. Are neglectful
  3. Lack consistency in discipline
  4. Minimize when their child has a physical, emotional, social or educational problem
  5. Shower their child with material objects in place of time, attention, communication and love
  6. "Give in" to their child's tantrums in order to "quiet" the child
  7. "Give in" to their child's inappropriate demands in order to appear "cool" or to act as a "buddy" rather than as a parent
  8. Fail to adequately monitor their child's whereabouts
  9. Fail to provide adequate supervision and guidance appropriate to their child's age and developmental level
  10. Leave their child to regulate his/her own behavior in a way not appropriate to their age and developmental level
  11. Allow their child to associate with people who could potentially put him or her in physical, sexual and/or legal danger
  12. Do not encourage a mutually respectful relationship

Resources

"My little girl had grown into a complete stranger. I couldn't talk to her, she wouldn't listen to me and she screamed that she hated me. One day she was gone. We found her and then we found Project Return, where she lived until she was able to find herself. In the process, I found my daughter again. If the door had not been open at the house on North Compo, she might be wandering the streets of New York, or worse."

Mother of past resident of Project Return's Residential program